Advertisement

FAS Tech Gurus Slam Rankings

Harvard officials say Princeton Review survey relied on faulty data

Harvard University did not make this year’s list of “America’s Most Connected Campuses,” released by the Princeton Review in October, but computer services officials at Harvard say this has nothing to do with the University’s technology or lack thereof. The problem was an inaccurate response to the survey.

“The basic fact is that most of the information is just plain wrong,” said Franklin Steen, director of computer services for the Faculty of Arts and Sciences. “We were very puzzled.”

The Princeton Review evaluated 357 schools on the sophistication of their computer technology, but Harvard was not on the list. The only Ivy League schools to break into the top 25 were Cornell University and the University of Pennsylvania, ranked six and nine, respectively.

The survey consists of 20 questions, each assigned a different point value based on its relative importance to campus life. Some of the more heavily weighted questions included the ratio of computers to students, and the availability of streaming video and audio of courses online. The questions asked whether the school has a wireless network and whether students can register for classes online.

The survey incorrectly cited Harvard as not having audio or video stream of courses available to students online.

Advertisement

“That’s ridiculous,” Steen said. “We’ve had that for a number of years.”

Steen said that the evaluation was also wrong about Harvard’s overall number of public computers, provision of web pages, access to Usenet groups, availability of multimedia equipment and network access in dormitory lounges.

“This survey gives such a wrong impression that if a student came here and expected to find what this survey said, they’d be completely shocked,” Steen said.

Erik Olson, who was in charge of the data collection and analysis for the rankings, said he has to trust his contact in each school to fill out the information accurately and completely.

“We expect that they will do their jobs as we are doing our jobs,” Olson said. “If they’re not the person to be in contact with anymore, tell us who is.”

But David L. Evans, who is in charge of filling out surveys and questionnaires that come to the Harvard Admissions Office, said that he did not have the time to get all the correct information.

“Mr. Olson and others tend to think that you can get hold of one person and that person can give you a response just like that,” Evans said. “You can’t easily do that, but we try to do the best we can.”

Evans said that there is no central place to find all of the information asked for by the survey.

“Who knows how many computers there are here? The registrar wouldn’t know that,” Evans said. “You would almost have to go to the Tech Center, but I didn’t this time.”

Supervisor of Student and Residential Computing Kevin S. Davis ’98 said he thinks that many of the questions asked on the survey were out-of-date or irrelevant.

Advertisement